The Committee leaning on schedule strength is predictably driving folks nuts
Rejoice, for this is the day that we Gump. There are a lot of bangers we need to run through this morning, so let’s get to it. One Alabama legend finally supplanted another, as Derrick Henry has now become the Tide’s most prolific scorer in history. It came, fittingly on a run between the tackles.
The ageless wonder is now 32, and he’s lost a step or two. But the NFL’s 7th all-time leading rusher are still plenty of miles left on that engine. He’s just 38 points behind Marcus Allen for 3rd all-time RB scorer, then LDT is 100 points ahead of that, which could be attainable. But1st is probably never going to be touched, Emmett’s 1052 points. Not every one got the benefit of that line and that dynasty.
Keep Rolling, King.
The little engine that could, did. And did some more. And then did some more. Marc notched his first triple-double in pro play, a feat he never even accomplished in his two-time All-American career at Alabama.
No. 16 Alabama basketball hosted Kennesaw State last night, and Owl HC Antoine Pettway got a full-on hero’s return and one of the warmest welcomes you’ll see. It’s okay to get misty about Pett — he’ll be back, when Nate Oats moves on to the NBA or Kentucky, Kansas etc. eventually lure him to a legacy job (don’t shoot the messenger).
As for the game itself, perhaps we should preface it with Nate’s concern going into the ballgame: Bama’s continued poor effort on the glass:
“You look at the four factors, like that’s really the only one that we’re poor at,” Oats said. “If we could get our rebounding cleaned up, I think our defense could really make a jump and put us in the conversation for, you know, one of the better teams in the country, so it’s what we’re focused on.
The aforementioned four factors — effective field goal percentage, turnover percentage, offensive rebounding percentage, and free throws attempted divided by field goals attempted — comprise a team’s adjusted offensive efficiency, and rebounding is indeed an outlier on a team performing at an elite level across the rest of the board.
Rebounding was always going to be a focal point given the team’s struggles on the glass last year, and it is clear that a lot of work needs to be done. Oats highlighted Drew Fielder, Brandon Garrison, Keitenn Bristow, Qayden Samuels, and Jaxon Richardson as players the team was going to need to rely on to get boards.
Did it improve last night? Nope. KSU led from whistle to whistle on the glass and outrebounded the far larger, far deeper Crimson Tide 41-40, despite the rout.

And afterwards he was predictably grumpy, about both that, and the second half defensive collapse. The Tide won 109-90, but the players didn’t seem to happy with their performance either.
Alabama beat the Commodores by 15, covered the spread, and stayed at 3rd in the CFP Committee’s weekly rankings. Texas beat LSU by 1, a team the Tide went B2A on last week, and raised by one spot, to No. 5. They also covered Vegas expectations. Tennessee was an erratic mess in Fayetteville, they have the country’s 123rd worst passing attack, and they did not cover against the Hogs, which is to say meet data-based expectations. They dropped a spot, to No. 9. Meanwhile, the team behind them last week, the Indiana Hoosiers, beat the No. 18 USC Trojans while the Vols were struggling with 3-6 Arkansas.
And I think we see the trend here, about meeting expectations and playing a reasonably balanced game, which the Vols alone did not do of the two-loss trio. That, and leaning into the metrics and the entire body of work.
Frankly, it’s driving people crazy too.
Alabama — inexplicably — remains at No. 3 despite their resume taking a massive hit this week. Alabama’s best win remains over Kentucky, who dropped to No. 16 this week after losing to Florida. The Crimson Tide were praised for not playing their best against Vanderbilt but still finding a way to win.
The committee had a big chance to fix their weird love affair with Alabama, but instead chose to dig their heels in even more.
But it’s not “weird,” it’s not inexplicable. It’s just math. Alabama has the No. 1 SOS and the No. 1 SOR. It is No. 7 in the BCS rankings, No. 3 per Sagarin; they have the No. 7 efficiency offense, the No. 4 efficiency defense, the No. 3 special teams units, they are the best team in the country in red zone scoring, and 7th in points allowed against teams with winning records. And they’ve been consistent against it, winning by 22.8 points per game, to UGA’s 23. It is a complete team, even if they’ve yet to play a complete game.
The CFP Chair explained very clearly why the Tide is still 3rd:
But, when you bring up strength of schedule and consistency, it drives the conspiracy nuts even loonier:
So, they finally did it. Less subjectivity, more reliance on hard data. Everyone can go to bed happy now, right?
Of course not. Why? Because any objective schedule strength data only bolsters the SEC.
Yes, the big, bad, Disney/media favorite SEC.
—
But here’s the thing: The SEC is playing tougher schedules this season. Its teams have gone 10-2 against the other P4 conferences and Notre Dame. The three other leagues are all below .500. And all of the SEC’s teams are playing a 10th P4 game. (There are four on Thanksgiving weekend.) Three Big Ten teams are not, including a 9-1 Indiana team that’s behind 8-2 Alabama and Texas.
The computer ratings aren’t all programmed by SEC engineers, and ESPN isn’t putting in conspiratorial calls to the committee room. The numbers say what they say, and the committee is finally placing more value on metrics than eye tests and body clocks.
Which is what most people always said they wanted.
Until they saw the results.
You got what you wanted. And maths don’t lie: The SEC is better, are playing tougher teams, beating everyone else, and deserve more spots at the table. So, no, Talty (on to his latest grift glazing the Longhorns, since that Lane Kiffin book didn’t sell so hot), it does not “defy logic. For the first time perhaps ever, it is almost wholly logical.
And, yes, that includes Alabama, College Football’s main character.
And, what we saw as a negative on Saturday, some folks saw as a positive: Not everyone could have done what Key did with almost no Team 1 reps on the road:
Be mad if you want; Alabama has almost certainly now secured a top four seed and a bye week for the College Football playoff…and that is a product of what it has done the entire three months, not the last three hours you can remember.
And, finally, your moment of levity.
Men are not simple creatures easily amused, and I’m tired of hearing that. But, we are content to simply be, to exist in the world and find small pleasures wherever they may arise. Keep finding that cool stick in the woods, king, or skipping the perfect rock along the banks of the backyard pond. Small things make the life worth living.
That’s it for now, you folks have a great day, and take care.
But, come back in about an hour, when we have our very first contest for you!
Roll Tide





I have to admit, I though UTexass would overtake us this week. Their final games are against 4-6 Aggie and 4-6 Arkansas. So, I don’t think that happens, with Alabama facing 7-4 Auburn to end the season (Sagarin No. 26).
Tennessee will do some more moving this week, but at best I see them getting to 6th behind the horns. Because that’s when H2H will actually matter.
I genuinely thought the committee would drop us a couple of spots, especially since so many (maybe all?) of our previous wins lost this past weekend. I can’t believe I’m about to say this buuuuuuuut maybe this committee isn’t complete ass?
That Stewart Mandel article I linked above explains it pretty well I think:
People demanded transparency. The CFP is giving it to them. And they have emphasized all year that they are going to use objective, empirical data — strength of schedule, strength of record, offensive and defensive efficiency, margin of victory
And now that people have that transparency, it turns out to favor the SEC. Because of course it would.
People are pissed off at the results of the very thing they demanded.
I’m old and vividly remember when Bama was boxed out of a National Championship in 1966 when Michigan State & ND were awarded co championship…..so in my opinion the “haters” can suck eggs!!!
Rbreik….appreciate the content you have created here on the TRL. It has become my go to page for the best Tide info and interesting takes!!! Also best to you on your health journey
thank you for the warm wishes and the kind words. We (and I) appreciate it!
As for ‘66, that reminds of a question I’ve often asked. I’m older, but not “old,” and I very clearly remember when split titles were routine. We didn’t blink twice at Tech/Washington in 1990, Michigan/Nebraska in ‘97 etc.
Why do we even need one “official” winner? The sport survived (indeed thrived) without them for over a century.
As a buddy of mine used to say, Rednecks, easily amused.
WRT to playoff rankings
Persons of loose sexual morals are, indeed, angry.
“he’ll be back, when Nate Oats moves on to the NBA or Kentucky, Kansas etc.”
I feel like it’s NBA or nothing for Nate at this point. Outside of money, everything else is starting to feel like a lateral move. I don’t think he has the personality for a legacy job either.
of course after he brings a natty to Tuscaloosa.
Your lips to god’s ears.
That’s been my suspicion since he declined UK. He’s always fawned over pro ball, tries to play pro ball, and tries to run his team and practices like a pro franchise.
Absolutely. His system is already installed at Alabama from the ground up. If he wins a title here, he proves that his system works and he’ll likely have his pick of NBA jobs. Kansas and Kentucky are likely to be rebuilds in one way or another (Kansas more of a cultural rebuild). Years long effort which is just deferring his dream of an NBA gig.
The other thing cynically that came to my mind as well is that he married his former subordinate after she had two years in an NBA front office.
I think it was a strategic marriage as much as anything — she has the connections for his dream job
Pat Forde lamented the CFP’s hard-on for the Tide, but finally got this point in (graf 19 of 21):
Buried the lede. 😂 😂 😂
Watching all the shit they’ve been whining about start to get weaponized against them has been the sweetest joy. These principleless dorks deserve it ten fold.
relatedly: They (and ND bros) are the ones who demanded transparency last year after Alabama got in.
Now they see the numbers behind the rankings, and they’re mad at math.
voles played aggie not hogs but same anyway
Yeah, they played right before third Saturday. That was just a brain fart.
and honestly, right now on a neutral field, I might even be inclined to take Arkansas over Texas A&M
I love the confusion between the shit-filled hog pen and the agholes. Even better if we lived in a world where the agholes and steers are both booted out of the SEC “for NOT being located in the southwest.” I can dream, right?
We had a defensive player celebrating a good play, his celebration was an impression from one of the make a wish kids who came to practice that week
that shit is cool, love the character of our team- culture- minus ak of course